You need not go far on a journey about Massachusetts, be it along the Freedom Trail in Boston, or a ride along the coastline of Cape Cod, to know that good car insurance is not only necessary as set by law, but it is that peace of mind on a car. I have found the best car insurance companies in Massachusetts after researching various policies and have experienced them myself. I will take you through the distinguishing characteristics of each of them, average prices, whether they are suitable for families and ordinary drivers, what sort of service you might anticipate, and what sort of local presence or address they have in the Bay State.
Best Car Insurance Companies in Massachusetts
1. State Farm — Trusted All-Around Choice
2. GEICO — Great for Low Rates & Online Convenience
3. Plymouth Rock Assurance — Local Comfort & Good Value
4. Travelers — Strong Coverage & Customization
5. Amica Mutual — Highly Rated Experience
5 Best Car Insurance Companies in Massachusetts
1. State Farm — Trusted All-Around Choice
In case you are as growth-and-stability-conscious as I am, State Farm traditionally takes first place in lists of the preferred insurers to go to in Massachusetts. It possesses an excellent network of agents throughout the state, so you can meet somebody in person, which comes in handy when you need to sort out the policies with children or more than one car. State Farm generally provides competitive premiums that have been lower than the average in Massachusetts, and it is also generally rated as reliable and very responsive to its customers.
The impression of being supported was what I liked most about State Farm. I was able to discuss with one of the local agents several different options about adding my teen driver to a policy without feeling pressured to do so. Those parents who are safety-conscious have several discounted choices of good students, safe driving schemes, and home + auto policies (bundles) that can keep the budget predictable.
Address: 101 Federal St, Boston, MA 02110 (Representative Office)
Average Price: Around $689 per year (~$57/month) for full coverage on average
2. GEICO — Great for Low Rates & Online Convenience
GEICO also frequently offers some of the lowest quotes in Massachusetts, which saves money, particularly with basic to full coverage. In my personal quote comparison, GEICO ranked much lower than state averages when I entered the profile of typical family drivers.
Their digital experience is very smooth, and it is one of the things that surprised me. Request a quote within minutes, and nearly everything can be handled via the app, making it the best option in cases of busy parents who have homework and soccer training. Its trade-off is that GEICO would be more online than it would be with physical agents, so you may not receive that human touch in the same way that you desire.
Nevertheless, GEICO is a good choice for most drivers who want simple, affordable protection and the latest technology.
Address: 225 Franklin Street, Boston, MA 02110
Average Price: Around $110–$113/month for full coverage estimates
3. Plymouth Rock Assurance — Local Comfort & Good Value
One of these companies is really Massachusetts-centric, Plymouth Rock Assurance. It is also one of the less complicated companies to deal with, based in the state and concentrated on local needs, in case you prefer to keep it easy. Plymouth Rock has high scores of ease of use, concrete discount deals, and convenient applications of managing policies according to recent comparisons.
Among the actual benefits that I observed, there is the simplicity of obtaining digital quotes and managing claims through the internet, and still placing a call to a real agent when you require a personal approach. They too have been known to sponsor such programs as the usage-based insurance that can allow teens and careful drivers to save money, which again is a nice bonus with the teens in your household.
In the case of shopping around, I would recommend that Plymouth Rock and GEICO be compared with each other. Better practical assistance is a way of rationalizing the higher cost to some households.
Address: 92 State St, Boston, MA 02109
Average Price: Roughly $1,573 per year for full coverage average
4. Travelers — Strong Coverage & Customization
The Travelers is a brand that you will find in almost every single best-of list, and I am not surprised. Having many customizable coverage plans, great customer care, and huge discounts (such as multi-policy and safe driving discounts), this insurance company is a good choice among drivers who do not want the minimum coverage and are willing to pay a little more to receive strong protection.
The remarkable aspect of Travelers during my research was the flexibility of the plans of their coverage, as you are able to add services such as roadside assistance, rental car insurance, and new car gap coverage. Their mobile and web applications are user-friendly, and the agents are knowledgeable about the traffic legislation and insurance in Massachusetts.
This is particularly ideal with Travelers as it may be a little costly in comparison to the lowest pricing options, but it is ideal with families that have fledgling drivers, or have high-value cars, and have long commutes.
Address: 385 Washington St, Boston, MA 02108
Average Price: Around $210/month for full coverage estimates
5. Amica Mutual — Highly Rated Experience
Amica Mutual is review-worthy in case you are the type of customer who appreciates the highest customer service and responsiveness. Amica may have a higher average premiums than discount companies, but it operates much better in these areas, claims handling, and customer satisfaction, which is an added value to many drivers.
After I had inquired with a few of my friends regarding their experiences, a few have complimented Amica on its claims procedure, particularly that the representatives were amiable, tolerant, and understandable, which is a significant factor when confronted with the stressful circumstance of an accident. And a stable claims team is invaluable with the bad weather roads in Massachusetts and the traffic congestion in the city.
The quality service and additional peace of mind that Amica is paying a little extra, however, makes it highly ranked by the consumer surveys by families that want that additional peace of mind,
Address: 1 Corporate Dr, Quincy, MA 02171
Average Price: Often higher than some competitors, around mid-to-higher range depending on coverage
Tips When Shopping for Car Insurance in Massachusetts
To have the best insurer does not mean that you have to go by the company name only, but what works best in your budget, driving record, and requirements. Some of the things that I learned in my experiences and research:
Compare quotes closely. The prices depend on your driving record, the level of your coverage, and the ZIP code. Recent data shows that full coverage is an average of 144/month statewide, though certain companies, such as GEICO, are much cheaper with selected drivers.
The first quote is not satisfactory. A difference of 10-20 a month will accumulate to over a year, so shop around.
Look for discounts. There can be safe driver, multi-policy, and good student discounts, which can significantly reduce your bill.
Consider coverage needs. Minimum liability may be cheap, yet full coverage will provide you with some peace of mind, particularly when you have children or are a commuter.
Talk to local agents. There are individuals who like face-to-face assistance, particularly when the individual is new to the state or when he has multiple number of vehicles to be insured.
Conclusion
Ultimately, no single car insurance is the perfect option in the state of Massachusetts, and yet, by understanding the advantages of each company and what is most important to you (price, services, digital-friendly tools, children on a policy, etc.), you will be able to make a well-informed decision. I have discovered that it is possible to have a balance between price and coverage quality, customer service, and claims comfort when you are behind the wheel.
I can also tell you how to get personalized quotes online and the information you would need (you just will need to tell me)!
About the Author
